I shipped skillcraft.ai !!!
Skillcraft helps you find the best learning resources tailored to your goals. Get a personalized roadmap with the best courses, books, and tutorials. Try it out, for free!
Up to date
Published
3 min read

Trevor I. Lasn

Building tools for developers. Currently building skillcraft.ai and blamesteve.lol

The 5:1 Rule: Effective Performance Reviews For High-Performing Teams

Research reveals the ideal ratio of positive to negative feedback within high performing teams

A study by Emily Heaphy and Marcial Losada examined how feedback patterns relate to team performance. Their research of 60 business teams found a correlation between team effectiveness and the ratio of positive to negative comments shared among team members.

PerformanceFeedback RatioComments
High-performing teams(Positive) 5.6:1 (Negative)Nearly six positive comments for each negative one
Medium-performing teams(Positive) 1.9:1 (Negative)Almost twice as many positive as negative comments
Low-performing teams(Positive) 0.36:1 (Negative)Nearly three negative comments for every positive one

Most organizations structure performance reviews with a roughly equal balance of positive and negative feedback. Some even follow the “sandwich method” - positive, negative, positive - creating a 2:1 ratio at best. According to the research, this approach falls significantly short of what drives optimal performance.

The 5:1 ratio isn’t arbitrary - it’s rooted in how our brains process different types of feedback during evaluation scenarios.

When employees receive criticism in a performance review, their brain’s threat response activates. The amygdala triggers stress hormones that narrow focus and put the employee in a defensive posture. This neurological response makes it difficult for them to fully process additional feedback or engage in productive discussion about growth opportunities.

Positive feedback, by contrast, activates the brain’s reward system. With sufficient positive reinforcement, employees experience dopamine release that enhances their receptivity to learning and growth discussions. This neurological state makes them more likely to engage constructively with improvement areas rather than defensively.

The 5:1 ratio creates a neurological environment where employees can remain open to critical feedback without becoming defensive or disengaged. It establishes psychological safety that makes performance reviews genuinely productive.

Applying the 5:1 Rule to Underperforming Employees

Managers often struggle with how to maintain the 5:1 ratio when reviewing genuinely underperforming employees. It can seem impossible or even dishonest to provide five positive comments for every critical one when someone is missing targets or causing problems.

For employees with multiple performance issues, spreading feedback across several conversations can maintain the ratio while still addressing all concerns over time. This approach prevents overwhelming the employee with criticism and gives them opportunity to make incremental improvements.

The 5:1 approach doesn’t mean ignoring or minimizing performance problems. Rather, it creates a psychological environment where employees can actually hear and implement critical feedback instead of becoming defensive. By maintaining the ratio even in difficult circumstances, managers increase the likelihood that their feedback will lead to genuine performance improvement rather than disengagement.


Found this article helpful? You might enjoy my free newsletter. I share dev tips and insights to help you grow your coding skills and advance your tech career.


Check out these related articles that might be useful for you. They cover similar topics and provide additional insights.

Reflections
4 min read

Build Your Army

If you want to do great things, you'll need people with skills that complement yours. You can't do everything yourself. You need a team. You need an army. You need to build your army.

Oct 4, 2024
Read article
Reflections
6 min read

Software Engineer Titles Have (Almost) Lost All Their Meaning

Examining the Devaluation of Software Engineer Titles and Its Impact on Tech Industry Integrity

Oct 20, 2024
Read article
Reflections
4 min read

Make It Work First Before Optimizing

Users don't care how elegant your code is. They care if it solves their problem.

Sep 27, 2024
Read article
Reflections
7 min read

The Real Cost of Meetings: What FAANG Companies Do Differently

Discover how FAANG companies like Amazon, Google, and Netflix reduce the hidden costs of meetings by embracing written communication and minimizing unnecessary gatherings.

Sep 17, 2024
Read article
Reflections
5 min read

Conway's Law: The Hidden Force Shaping Your Software Architecture

If you've ever wondered why your carefully planned software architecture ends up looking suspiciously like your org chart, you're not alone. Welcome to the world of Conway's Law.

Sep 24, 2024
Read article
Reflections
5 min read

What's the Number One Thing Holding Most People Back from Reaching Their Full Potential?

Discover the biggest obstacle to success in tech and learn how to overcome it

Sep 29, 2024
Read article
Reflections
4 min read

Staying Motivated While Building Your Startup: A Balanced Approach

Building a startup is an exhilarating journey, filled with highs and lows

Dec 17, 2023
Read article
Reflections
3 min read

Engineering Managers Should Write Code

Engineering managers who stop writing code lose touch with their teams and become ineffective leaders

Sep 18, 2024
Read article
Reflections
4 min read

How to Launch Software Projects On Time and On Budget

Learn the art of scope management to keep your projects fixed in time and cost

Oct 7, 2024
Read article

This article was originally published on https://www.trevorlasn.com/blog/the-5-1-rule. It was written by a human and polished using grammar tools for clarity.