Vanta Logo
SPONSOR
Automate SOC 2 & ISO 27001 compliance with Vanta. Get $1,000 off.
Published
2 min read
Up to date

Trevor I. Lasn

Staff Software Engineer, Engineering Manager

Honey Quietly Hijacked Creator Revenue Through Affiliate Link Switching

Honey's controversial affiliate link practices and what it teaches us about Silicon Valley's ethics

The browser extension Honey, now owned by PayPal, built its reputation on helping users save money through automated coupon testing. But beneath this consumer-friendly facade lay a controversial practice that directly impacted content creators’ livelihoods.

When users installed the Honey browser extension, it would automatically replace creators’ affiliate links with Honey’s own affiliate codes. This meant that when a viewer clicked through a creator’s product recommendation and made a purchase, the commission went to Honey instead of the creator who actually influenced the sale.

This practice wasn’t clearly disclosed to creators or users. Many content creators only discovered the issue when they noticed unexpected drops in their affiliate earnings. The technical implementation was clever but ethically questionable - Honey’s extension would scan pages for affiliate links and seamlessly substitute their own tracking codes.

The genius of Honey’s business model was its ability to monetize other people’s work. While presenting itself as a coupon-finding tool, a significant portion of its revenue came from intercepting affiliate commissions. This created a situation where Honey profited from content creators’ product recommendations without their knowledge or consent.

PayPal’s $4 billion acquisition of Honey in 2019 demonstrates just how profitable this model was. The deal raised eyebrows in the creator community, but by then, the practice was deeply embedded in Honey’s operations.

This situation highlights a critical lesson: when a service is free, you need to understand how it makes money. Honey’s business model wasn’t just about finding coupons - it was about intercepting and redirecting revenue streams from creators to themselves.

The lack of transparency is particularly troubling. Many users installed Honey believing they were simply getting a tool to save money, unaware they were participating in redirecting income from content creators they followed and trusted.

The fact that PayPal, a major financial services company, saw value in this model rather than ethical concerns is telling. It reflects a broader pattern in tech where questionable practices are overlooked if they’re profitable enough.

If you found this article helpful, you might enjoy my free newsletter. I share developer tips and insights to help you grow your skills and career.


More Articles You Might Enjoy

If you enjoyed this article, you might find these related pieces interesting as well. If you like what I have to say, please check out the sponsors who are supporting me. Much appreciated!

Tech
5 min read

Is Age Really a Factor in Tech?

Silicon Valley has a reputation for youth worship. The 'move fast and break things' mentality often translates to a preference for younger, supposedly more adaptable workers.

Oct 8, 2024
Read article
Tech
3 min read

Google is Killing Information Economics on the Internet

Google’s Gemini pulls summaries from websites and slaps them directly into the search results

Sep 11, 2024
Read article
Tech
8 min read

Apple's Secret Sauce: The Untold Stories Behind Its Success

Diving deep into the lesser-known factors that propelled Apple from a garage startup to a tech titan

Sep 30, 2024
Read article
Tech
3 min read

Tattoos Won't Break Your Tech Career

Building a tech career with a sword tattooed on my neck

Dec 10, 2024
Read article
Tech
10 min read

Amazon's Rise to Tech Titan: A Story of Relentless Innovation

How Jeff Bezos' 'Day 1' philosophy turned an online bookstore into a global powerhouse

Sep 30, 2024
Read article
Tech
5 min read

Cloudflare's AI Content Control: Savior or Threat to the Open Web?

How Cloudflare's new AI management tools could revolutionize content creation, potentially reshaping the internet landscape for both website owners and AI companies.

Sep 24, 2024
Read article
Tech
4 min read

When Regex Goes Wrong

Issues and catastrophic failures caused by regex

Aug 29, 2024
Read article
Tech
5 min read

Cloudflare Study: 39% of Companies Losing Control of Their IT and Security Environment

New research reveals a shocking loss of control in corporate IT environments

Oct 3, 2024
Read article
Tech
5 min read

The Fight to Free JavaScript from Oracle's Control

The creator of JavaScript and Node.js are challenging Oracle's control over the JavaScript name

Nov 23, 2024
Read article

Become a better engineer

Here are engineering resources I've personally vetted and use. They focus on skills you'll actually need to build and scale real projects - the kind of experience that gets you hired or promoted.

Many companies have a fixed annual stipend per engineer (e.g. $2,000) for use towards learning resources. If your company offers this stipend, you can forward them your invoices directly for reimbursement. By using my affiliate links, you support my work and get a discount at the same!


This article was originally published on https://www.trevorlasn.com/blog/honey. It was written by a human and polished using grammar tools for clarity.